The commission inside a stop-loss premium
For employers with a self-funded health plan. How a broker's commission can be built into a medical stop-loss premium, a calculator that uses only your numbers, what the federal rule lets the plan ask for, and a checklist. It works only from the numbers you type. Nothing leaves your browser.
Private by design. Everything is worked out in this browser tab. Nothing you type is sent anywhere, and this page cannot make a connection after it loads. What you type is kept only in this tab until you close it or press Clear everything.
How the commission gets into the price
We are not lawyers, actuaries, brokers or benefits advisers, and nothing here is advice for your plan. This is what the sources below say, in plain words, with our own arithmetic marked as ours. Every link opens the source in a new tab.
What stop-loss is
In a self-funded plan, the employer's plan pays health claims itself instead of buying a policy that takes the risk. Stop-loss insurance covers "claims costs that exceed a set amount." The Labor Department notes that "More often, it only insures the employer against losses" (DOL Technical Release 2014-01 (opens in a new tab)). Specific stop-loss covers high claims for one person; aggregate stop-loss covers total claims above a set level.
How a carrier sets the price
An actuarial textbook describes premium as expected claims plus expenses plus profit, and the target loss ratio as "the percentage of each premium dollar that is intended to pay for the projected" claims and fixed costs. It says commission "is usually a percentage of the premium" (Casualty Actuarial Society, 2016 (opens in a new tab)). The book is written for property and casualty insurance, but the algebra is general. An actuarial body's stop-loss report asked carriers for their "current pricing target loss ratio" (American Academy of Actuaries, 2016 (opens in a new tab)).
Why the premium rises by more than the rate
Say the carrier aims to spend a share N of premium on claims when there is no commission. A commission of c percent of premium leaves N minus c for claims, so to cover the same claims the premium has to grow by N divided by (N minus c). In percent terms that is always more than the commission rate: a 5 percent commission means at least 5.26 percent more premium. How much more depends on N. At 80 percent it is 6.67 percent (0.80 / 0.75); at 70 percent, 7.69 percent. This is our arithmetic on the textbook formula, not a measured fact about any carrier.
What is not known
The extra beyond the commission itself only appears if the carrier's other charges (expenses, profit, premium tax) are a percent of premium, because then they are charged on the commission too. If they are fixed dollars, adding a commission raises the premium by exactly the commission. We found no source that says how stop-loss carriers build those charges, so we cannot say the extra goes to the carrier. A quote from the carrier with no commission in it is the only way to know.
Not every kind of pay grows with the premium
A commission set as a percent of premium grows with every renewal increase at the same rate, with no added work required. A commission set per employee per month moves with headcount, not price, and a flat fee stays where it is agreed. Carriers describe base commissions as "a percentage of the premium or set amount per employee" (a carrier (opens in a new tab)). Some carriers pay lower rates at renewal than in the first year (an agency blog (opens in a new tab)), which works the other way.
The premium can pay more than the broker
Actuaries writing in 2020 said rates for a 100-life group "typically include fees for agents and underwriters," and that "the TPA will often be compensated by the stop-loss carrier from the stop-loss premium" (Society of Actuaries, 2020 (opens in a new tab)). The TPA is the company that runs your claims. So a commission figure may not be all the pay inside the premium.
Dated figures, for context only
We found no current, published range for base stop-loss commissions, so we do not offer a "typical" figure. One survey of 24 carriers, with 2016 data, said "Average supplemental commissions ranged from 3% to 5%" (survey, 2017 (opens in a new tab)). A 2026 survey of plan sponsors noted that in its figures "broker commissions are not removed," that they "may be hidden, if not unknown, to respondents," and found 2026 renewal increases of 13.6 to 15.9 percent (survey, 2026 (opens in a new tab)). For fully insured plans, not stop-loss, a 2022 study of 2017 filings found a median commission of 4.1 percent of premium (study, 2022 (opens in a new tab)).
The 80/85 percent rule does not appear to cap this
The ACA's medical loss ratio rule is written for health insurance issuers (42 U.S.C. 300gg-18 (opens in a new tab)). Stop-loss sold to employers "generally is not treated as health insurance under State law" (DOL (opens in a new tab)), so, by our reading, that floor does not cap how much of a stop-loss premium goes to costs other than claims.
The worked example
This is our own illustration, worked out from the formula above. Premium rise in dollars equals the commission dollars divided by N. The part beyond the commission is what the other percent-of-premium charges add on the commission itself.
| Ratio with no commission | Premium, no commission | Premium with a 5% commission | Rise | Commission dollars | Premium rise in dollars | Rise beyond the commission | Premium with a 10% commission | Rise |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 70% | $1,428,571 | $1,538,462 | 7.69% | $76,923 | $109,890 | $32,967 | $1,666,667 | 16.67% |
| 75% | $1,333,333 | $1,428,571 | 7.14% | $71,429 | $95,238 | $23,810 | $1,538,462 | 15.38% |
| 80% | $1,250,000 | $1,333,333 | 6.67% | $66,667 | $83,333 | $16,667 | $1,428,571 | 14.29% |
| 85% | $1,176,471 | $1,250,000 | 6.25% | $62,500 | $73,529 | $11,029 | $1,333,333 | 13.33% |
premium with commission = expected claims / (N - c) premium with no commission = expected claims / N rise = N / (N - c) - 1 example: 0.80 / 0.75 - 1 = 6.67 percent if the other charges are fixed dollars: rise = c / (1 - c) example: 0.05 / 0.95 = 5.26 percent
The fair case for commission in the premium
- One bill. The broker is paid through the premium, so a small employer has no separate invoice, budget line or approval step.
- Pay scales with size. In fully insured plans, commission rates fall as plans grow, so smaller cases pay a higher rate and larger ones a lower rate (study, 2022 (opens in a new tab)). Large groups more often use a consultant on a flat fee (Society of Actuaries, 2020 (opens in a new tab)).
- Brokers do real work. For stop-loss that can mean marketing the case to several carriers, negotiating contract terms and handling the renewal. Lasers (higher attachment points for certain people) and run-out periods are among the terms a buyer has to settle (Society of Actuaries, 2020 (opens in a new tab)).
- Disclosure is already required for many arrangements, in writing, to a responsible plan fiduciary (see below). The issue this page helps with is understanding and comparing, not secrecy by default.
- Fees have their own trade-offs. A flat fee does not fall when the work does, and a fee-based broker may receive other pay that must be disclosed too.
- You can choose. Carriers offer fee-based cases with no base commission in the stop-loss premium (a carrier (opens in a new tab)).
Your numbers
Type the numbers from your own quote. Everything below is arithmetic on what you type. It is not a quote, and it says nothing about whether a price or a commission is fair. A real quote from the carrier with no commission in it is the only way to know what the premium would be.
Numbers: use a dot for decimals, like 5.5 or 250000.50. A comma is read only as a thousands separator in a dollar amount, like 250,000.00. Anything we cannot read for certain is not used, and we say why.
How these are worked out
P = the annual premium you typed, c = commission rate, N = the ratio you chose commission this year K = P x c (or PEPM x employees x 12) premium with the commission simply taken out = P - K model, carrier re-prices with no commission: premium rise R = K / N premium with no commission = P - R rise beyond the commission = R - K rise as a percent of that premium = K / (P x N - K) (= c / (N - c) for a percent) if the other charges were fixed dollars: K / (P - K) (= c / (1 - c)) year by year: premium next year = premium x (1 + renewal increase) percent commission each year = that year's premium x c PEPM each year = PEPM x employees x 12, headcount held level flat fee each year = the fee you typed, held level
Rounding: every dollar figure is worked out in whole cents with exact integer arithmetic and rounded to the nearest cent, half a cent rounding up. Each year's premium is rounded to the cent before the next year is worked out. Percentages are rounded to two decimal places, half up, from the exact figures.
What you can ask for
This is the federal rule as the sources state it. It is not legal advice; an ERISA attorney can tell you how it applies to your plan.
- The rule. A plan can pay for services under an exemption only "if no more than reasonable compensation is paid therefor." For group health plans, a contract for services is not "reasonable" under that exemption unless the broker or consultant makes the disclosures below (29 U.S.C. 1108(b)(2) (opens in a new tab), ERISA section 408(b)(2)(B)).
- Who must disclose. A broker or consultant who reasonably expects $1,000 or more in direct or indirect pay for services to the plan. Brokerage and consulting on "stop-loss insurance" are named in the statute's lists (29 U.S.C. 1108(b)(2)(B)(ii) (opens in a new tab)).
- To whom and how. The statute says the provider "shall disclose to a responsible plan fiduciary, in writing," meaning a plan fiduciary with authority to have the plan enter into, extend or renew the contract. It includes the services, whether the provider will act as a fiduciary, all direct pay, all indirect pay and who pays it, transaction-based pay such as commissions passed among the provider, its affiliates and subcontractors, and any pay on termination (29 U.S.C. 1108(b)(2)(B)(iii) (opens in a new tab)).
- It may be a formula. Pay "may be expressed as a monetary amount, formula, or a per capita charge" (1108(b)(2)(B)(ii)(II) (opens in a new tab)). So, by our reading, "5 percent of premium" can be the disclosure, without a dollar figure. Our calculator turns a formula into dollars.
- When. Reasonably in advance of signing, and again on extension or renewal; changes within 60 days of the provider learning of them (1108(b)(2)(B)(v) (opens in a new tab)).
- If it is not provided. The arrangement does not qualify for the exemption. The fiduciary keeps relief only if it did not know, reasonably believed the disclosure was made, and on learning of the gap "requests in writing that the covered service provider furnish such information." If the provider does not comply within 90 days of the request, the fiduciary must also notify the Labor Department, no later than 30 days after the provider refuses or the 90 days end, whichever is earlier, to keep that relief; and if the gap concerns future services and is not fixed promptly after the 90 days, the fiduciary must end the contract "as expeditiously as possible, consistent with such duty of prudence" (1108(b)(2)(B)(viii) (opens in a new tab)).
- The Labor Department's guidance. Field Assistance Bulletin 2021-03, dated December 30, 2021, says the rule applies to contracts "entered into, extended, or renewed on or after December 27, 2021", that covered plans include "both insured and self-insured group health plans," and lists stop-loss insurance among the services. Pending further guidance, the Department will not treat a broker or consultant as having failed to make the required disclosures if it made them "in accordance with a good faith, reasonable interpretation" of the statute (DOL FAB 2021-03 (opens in a new tab)).
- Not settled. In a common setup, the stop-loss policy is owned by the employer, not the plan, and paid from the employer's own money. The Labor Department has said such a policy was not a plan asset where, among other facts, the employer was the only insured and payee, the plan took no employee contributions, benefits did not depend on the insurance, and participants had no claim on the policy (DOL Advisory Opinion 92-02A (opens in a new tab), which applies only to the facts it was given). Whether the disclosure rule reaches a broker whose only work is placing an employer-owned stop-loss policy is not settled: the statute names stop-loss as a service "provided to a covered plan," and neither the statute nor the bulletin says how that applies when the employer is the policyholder. Ask an ERISA attorney.
The Form 5500
Schedule A of the Form 5500 is filed when plan benefits are provided by an insurance company, and its line 2 reports the commissions and fees on each contract, including bonuses. But the instructions say employer-owned stop-loss policies paid only from the employer's general assets, with no employee contributions, "generally are not plan assets and are not reportable on Schedule A." A stop-loss policy that is a plan asset is reported (2025 Form 5500 instructions (opens in a new tab)). By our reading of the same instructions, many plans with under 100 participants that pay claims from the employer's general assets file no Form 5500 at all (this assumes no employee contributions or trust and a plan that is not a multiple employer arrangement filing Form M-1). So a stop-loss commission often does not show up in public filings.
A checklist to take to your broker
Tick them off as you go, then copy or print the list.
Honest limits
- We are not lawyers, actuaries, brokers or benefits advisers. Nothing here is advice for your plan or a recommendation about any broker, carrier or policy.
- For what the law requires of your plan, ask an ERISA attorney.
- Every figure in the calculator is arithmetic on the numbers you typed. It is not a quote. The model of a re-priced premium depends entirely on the ratio you chose; only a quote from the carrier with no commission in it tells you the real number.
- We name no company or person and make no claim about any of them.
- Laws, guidance and market practice change. The sources below were read on November 15, 2026; later changes are not reflected.
Sources
- 29 U.S.C. 1108(b)(2), ERISA section 408(b)(2), U.S. Code 2023 edition (opens in a new tab) (govinfo.gov, U.S. Government Publishing Office)
- Field Assistance Bulletin No. 2021-03, December 30, 2021 (opens in a new tab) (U.S. Department of Labor)
- Technical Release 2014-01 on stop-loss insurance, November 6, 2014 (opens in a new tab) (U.S. Department of Labor)
- 2025 Instructions for Form 5500 (opens in a new tab) (U.S. Department of Labor)
- Advisory Opinion 92-02A, January 17, 1992 (opens in a new tab) (U.S. Department of Labor)
- 42 U.S.C. 300gg-18, medical loss ratio (opens in a new tab) (govinfo.gov, U.S. Government Publishing Office)
- Basic Ratemaking, Fifth Edition, May 2016 (study note) (opens in a new tab) (Casualty Actuarial Society)
- Report on the Stop Loss Factors, November 14, 2016 (opens in a new tab) (American Academy of Actuaries)
- Health Watch newsletter, October 2020, on buying and selling employer stop-loss (opens in a new tab) (Society of Actuaries)
- 2016 employer stop-loss market survey, published June 1, 2017 (opens in a new tab) (an actuarial consulting firm)
- 2026 Medical Stop-Loss Premium Survey of plan sponsors (opens in a new tab) (a stop-loss consultancy with a benefits education society)
- Overview of producer compensation (undated) (opens in a new tab) (a large health carrier)
- Broker blog post, April 2, 2024 (promotional) (opens in a new tab) (a general insurance agency)
- Peer-reviewed study of broker commissions, Medical Care Research and Review, 2022 (author-hosted copy) (opens in a new tab) (university researchers)
Page written November 15, 2026 from sources read November 15, 2026. More free tools: Known Quantity for Good.
These tools are free and stay free. If one helped and you can spare it, a tip helps keep them that way. Never required.